On 13-14 November 1918, representatives of the Central Romanian National Council met in Arad with a delegation sent by the Hungarian government and led by Oszkár Jászi. Vasile Goldiș took part as a Council member. The talks matter because they show which solutions were considered before the Assembly at Alba Iulia and why Romanian leaders chose to seek a public decision by their representatives.
What the Council had demanded before the meeting
In early November, the Council was working in Arad as the old imperial and Hungarian authority rapidly weakened. The Oradea Declaration had affirmed the Romanians’ right of self-determination. The next question was who would exercise power in territories inhabited by Romanians.
The note sent to the Budapest government on 9 November, drafted by Goldiș on the Council’s behalf, demanded the transfer of political, administrative and military authority. The government did not accept this demand. It chose to negotiate and sent Jászi, the minister responsible for the nationalities question, to lead a delegation to Arad.
The meeting was more than a dispute over wording. The two sides were discussing who had the right to decide the future of a territory and its peoples. At the end of a war, maintaining order and preventing violence were also practical concerns. That is why the talks took place despite the distance between the two sides’ positions in principle.
Autonomy or self-determination
The Hungarian delegation sought a solution that would keep the territories linked to Hungary while offering autonomy or administrative concessions. The Council’s leaders maintained that the Romanian nation must be able to decide its own future. The difference concerned political authority, not merely the degree of autonomy.
Goldiș and the other participants were not negotiating as individuals. They represented a body made up of Romanian nationalists and Romanian social democrats. Any agreement would have had to be defended before the communities and their delegates. The failure to reach an agreement does not make the talks meaningless. They clarified the limits of Budapest’s proposed solution.
Historians have also discussed the part these conversations played in formulating principles concerning the other peoples living in the same territories. A study of the Alba Iulia Resolution shows that, in their replies to the Hungarian delegation, Romanian leaders affirmed a commitment to respect the rights of other communities. This leads towards the Resolution’s provision on national and religious freedom. It should not, however, be assumed that the talks in Arad dictated the entire text of the Resolution.
What followed the failed talks
After the meeting, the Romanian leadership had to decide how to make its choice. Some proposed proclaiming union immediately. Goldiș supported calling a representative assembly. The argument recorded in historical accounts was that an act decided by a small group would be easier to challenge than a decision made by delegates from the territories concerned.
This was not a delay without purpose. Organising an assembly required calls to attend, a system of representation, travel by the delegates and preparation of a political text. In the days remaining before 1 December, Goldiș worked on the manifesto To the Peoples of the World and a draft Resolution. The Arad press helped communicate the call to the Assembly.
The talks therefore had an indirect political consequence. They made clear that agreement with the Budapest government was impossible on the Council’s terms of self-determination. A decision would have to be sought in another setting: the National Assembly at Alba Iulia.
Reading accounts of the Arad talks
Sources about those days sometimes use old-style and new-style dates, and Jászi’s name may appear with different spellings. It is therefore useful to check the calendar and the people involved before comparing documents. More importantly, an account written after the Union may present the outcome as inevitable. During the talks, participants did not yet know exactly how the Assembly would be organised or what reactions would follow.
Arad was where a negotiated way out of the crisis was tested. The failure of the talks accelerated preparations for a collective decision. Goldiș’s role is visible in the connection between drafting the note, taking part in negotiations and insisting that the future be decided by representatives meeting in public.
Read also
- The Central Romanian National Council
- The manifesto To the Peoples of the World
- The Alba Iulia Resolution
Sources
- Historia, portrait of Vasile Goldiș as an ideologist of the Great Union
- Historia, study of Arad as the seat of the Central Romanian National Council
- Historia, study of the Union Resolution of 1 December 1918
- AGERPRES, report on Ștefan Cicio Pop’s house in Arad